Here is what to expect: our coin appraisals are free and happen one on one, in front of you. We check each coin's date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal under a loupe, weigh gold and silver on a scale you can read and hand you a written offer item by item. You can sell that day, sell part or keep everything.
Booking the appointment
Call (726) 465-0380 and we will call you back the same business day. Appointments run Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, and each one is private and one-on-one. We set where to meet when you book.
It helps to tell us roughly what you have when you call. A jar of old dimes, a few gold coins, three albums of pennies and a safe full of an estate all take different amounts of time.
You don't need names, dates or a count. If the collection is large or part of an estate, ask about a home visit.
You can book for a parent or another relative. The owner of the coins is welcome to come and watch, and whoever sells brings the photo ID.
Before the day, gather everything into one box or bag so nothing gets left at home. If coins are spread across a safe, a closet and a dresser drawer, collect them first. Leave rolls unopened and skip sorting the coins into piles by what you think they're worth, because we do that at the table.
What to bring
Bring the coins the way they are now. Cleaning a coin lowers its grade, and collectors pay far less for a cleaned coin, so leave tarnish and toning alone.
Coins in PCGS or NGC slabs should stay sealed. Proof sets and mint sets should stay in their original packaging.
Bring everything, including the coins you think are worthless. We sort collector coins from melt coins as part of the appraisal, and the scarce date in a collection is often sitting in the pile the owner set aside. A short list covers it:
You don't need to research anything first. Some sellers look up their coins online and arrive with printed prices, which is fine.
Keep in mind that a retail listing shows what a seller hopes to get, and a melt calculator ignores date and grade. We will walk you through how our numbers compare.
- All the coins, paper money and bullion you want looked at
- Albums, rolls, holders and boxes, even empty ones with writing on them
- Proof and mint sets in their original packaging
- Any gold or silver jewelry you are thinking of selling
- Old receipts or lists the collector kept
- A government-issued photo ID if you plan to sell
What happens at the table
We go through the coins one at a time while you watch. Each one is checked under a loupe for date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal.
Grades run from 1 to 70 on the Sheldon scale. Coins already graded by PCGS or NGC have the grade on the slab label, and we look at the coin through the plastic as well.
Gold and silver go on a calibrated scale with the readout facing you. Gold jewelry is sorted by karat first, using the stamps you will find on clasps and inside rings: 10K is 41.7% gold, 14K is 58.3%, 18K is 75% and 22K is 91.6%. Each karat group is then weighed in grams or pennyweights, where one pennyweight is 1.555 grams.
As we work, coins get sorted into two groups. Collector coins are priced on their date and grade.
Melt coins are priced on their metal. That sorting keeps a better date from being priced as bullion.
Paper money gets the same one-at-a-time look. We check each note's series, seal color and serial number, since a star by the serial marks a replacement note and small-size red seals mark United States Notes. Silver certificates redeem only at face value today, so anything they bring above face comes from collectors.
A handful of coins takes about 10 minutes. A large collection can take 30 to 60 minutes. You can ask questions the whole way through.
How the offer is figured
Offers follow the live spot price for gold and silver and current collector demand for numismatic coins. For collector coins we check published price guides, dealer wholesale sheets and recent auction results. Here is what we look at on each coin and why:
For a melt coin, the offer comes from its pure gold or silver content. A Morgan dollar holds 0.7734 troy ounces of silver, and a $20 double eagle holds 0.9675 troy ounces of gold. For a collector coin, that metal is the floor, and the date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal decide how far above it the offer goes.
Slabbed coins from PCGS or NGC are often quicker to price because the grade is already on the label. We still look at eye appeal, since two coins in the same grade can sell for different amounts.
Metal prices move during the day, so the offer reflects the spot price at the time you see it. Collector demand moves more slowly, over months instead of hours.
| What we check | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Date | Some years were struck in small numbers and sell to collectors well above common years |
| Mint mark | The same date can be common from one mint and scarce from another, such as Carson City Morgans |
| Grade | Higher grades on the 1 to 70 scale bring more, and a cleaned coin brings far less |
| Eye appeal | Two coins with the same grade can differ in toning and surface, and collectors pay for the nicer one |
| Weight and purity | Sets the melt value, which is the floor for any gold or silver piece |
After you see the offer
You get a written offer that lists each item and what we would pay for it. Take your time reading it. Ask about any line that surprises you, and we will show you the coin and explain how we priced it.
If you accept, you are paid the same day, in cash or by a same-day wire to your bank for larger sales. You can also sell part of what you brought and keep the rest.
If you decline, you take everything home along with the written list. The appraisal is free, and there is no obligation to sell.
If you want to think it over or talk with family, take the list home. Coins priced on their metal follow the spot price, so their offer may differ if you come back on another day.
For larger sales, a same-day wire to your bank saves you carrying a large amount of cash home. Smaller sales are usually paid in cash at the table.
Purchase appraisals and certified appraisals
Our appraisals are free purchase appraisals. They tell you what we would pay for your coins today.
They are not certified appraisals for court, probate, insurance or IRS use. If you need one of those, your attorney or insurance agent can tell you what kind to get.
A certified appraisal is a separate service, usually paid, that puts a value on items for a legal or insurance purpose. Ours answers one question: what we would pay for each item today.
The written list still helps families dividing an estate or working with an executor or attorney, because everyone can see the same items and the same offer. If you plan to talk to more than one buyer, these questions will help you compare:
- Will you look at each coin, or weigh the whole lot together?
- Can I see the scale while you weigh my gold and silver?
- Will I get the offer in writing, item by item?
- Will you sort collector coins from melt coins before pricing?
- Is there any charge if I decide not to sell?
- How and when will I be paid?
Booking a coin appraisal around San Antonio
We book coin appraisals by phone for sellers all over San Antonio and Bexar County. Calls come from Stone Oak along US 281 north of Loop 1604, from Helotes on the northwest edge toward the Hill Country, from Castle Hills inside Loop 410 and from Schertz and Cibolo along the I-35 corridor. Where to meet is set when you book, and every appointment is private.
A lot of what we appraise here comes from military households tied to Joint Base San Antonio, at Fort Sam Houston, Lackland and Randolph. Retirees bring proof sets bought year after year, silver dollars and coins picked up during their service. Long-time families in Alamo Heights and Monte Vista bring albums a grandparent filled, and the written list gives everyone in the family the same numbers to talk over.
Sellers in New Braunfels, Seguin and Boerne book the same way as sellers downtown. Most bring coins and gold jewelry together, and one appointment covers both, with the jewelry sorted by karat and weighed.
For a large collection or an estate that would be hard to move, ask about a home visit when you call. Appointments run Monday to Friday from 9am to 5pm, and we call back the same business day at (726) 465-0380.
Ready to sell? See how we handle free coin appraisals in San Antonio, read about selling coins in San Antonio, or call (726) 465-0380.