Live spot GoldLiveSilverLivePlatinumLive
Mon to Fri, 9am to 5pm · Offers start from today's spot price
San Antonio Coin Buyers

What Old Coins Are Worth More Than Face Value

Coin values · San Antonio Coin Buyers · Updated November 5, 2026

Quick answer

An old coin is worth more than face value if it contains silver or gold, if it is a scarce date or mint mark, or if it is in unusually high grade. Any U.S. dime, quarter or half dollar dated 1964 or earlier holds 90% silver. Most coins from 1965 on, worn wheat cents and circulated state quarters are worth face value.

Pile of 90% silver dimes, quarters and halves sorted for a San Antonio seller

Start with the metal

The quickest way to sort a jar of old coins is by what they are made of. Silver and gold coins have a melt value that follows the live spot price, and that value is almost always above face. Copper-nickel clad coins have no metal premium at all.

Dates tell you most of what you need. U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars from 1964 or before carry 90% silver.

One dollar in face value of those coins holds about 0.715 troy ounce of silver, which is why a roll of old dimes is worth many times its face. Look at the edge: a silver coin shows a solid silver stripe, while a clad coin shows a copper band.

A few later coins carry silver too. Kennedy half dollars from 1965 to 1970 are 40% silver.

Jefferson nickels from 1942 to 1945, called war nickels, are 35% silver and are worth more than other nickels for that reason. Morgan and Peace dollars are 90% silver, and each holds 0.7734 troy ounce.

Silver is easy to overlook in small amounts. A few old dimes do not look like much, but rolls of them add up, and we weigh every silver coin on a calibrated scale in front of you.

CoinSilver contentWhat sets the price
Dimes, quarters, halves dated 1964 and earlier90%Silver weight, plus collector demand for better dates
Kennedy halves 1965 to 197040%Mostly silver weight
War nickels 1942 to 194535%Mostly silver weight
Morgan and Peace dollars90%Silver weight, date, mint mark and grade
Coins dated 1965 and later (other than those halves)NoneFace value, unless scarce or in a proof or mint set

Gold coins

Any gold coin is worth money. The United States struck gold coins for circulation until 1933, in $20, $10, $5, $2.50 and $1 sizes, and those classic coins are 90% gold. A $20 double eagle alone holds 0.9675 troy ounce of gold.

Pre-1933 gold is priced on its gold content plus collector demand, and some dates and mint marks bring far more than the metal. Modern bullion coins, such as the American Gold Eagle, the Krugerrand, the Canadian Maple Leaf and the Mexican 50 pesos, are priced mostly on their gold weight and the live spot price.

Gold coins sometimes hide in jewelry. A coin set in a bezel on a necklace or a ring still has its gold, and we weigh and price it at the appointment.

Gold-colored coins are not always gold. Sacagawea and Presidential dollars look golden but contain no gold and are worth face value. Real gold coins feel heavy for their size.

Collector coins: dates, mint marks, grade and errors

Some coins are worth more than their metal because collectors want them. A scarce date or mint mark, a coin in unusually sharp condition, or a coin from a short commemorative run can bring a premium well above melt. The 1893-S Morgan dollar is a famous example of a scarce date, while the 1921 Morgan is a common one.

Grade matters as much as the date. Coins are graded on the 1 to 70 Sheldon scale, and a coin with little or no wear is worth more than the same coin worn smooth. Coins graded by PCGS or NGC come sealed in plastic holders called slabs, which makes them easier to price.

Mint errors can also carry a premium. Coins struck off center, struck twice or struck on the wrong blank are wanted by collectors.

Real errors come from the Mint. Damage done after a coin left the Mint, like a dent or a scratch, is not an error and adds nothing.

Proof sets and mint sets are worth a look too. Proof coins are struck twice on polished dies for collectors, and many silver proof sets carry 90% silver coins. Leave sets in their original packaging.

  • Classic commemorative halves, such as the Texas Centennial half dollar
  • Carson City (CC) Morgan dollars
  • Pre-1933 U.S. gold coins
  • Spanish and Mexican 8 reales
  • Silver proof sets
  • Large-size paper money, star notes and National Bank Notes

Coins that are usually worth face value

Plenty of old coins are worth only what they say on them, and it helps to know which ones before you book an appointment. Most dimes and quarters dated 1965 and later are copper-nickel clad, nickels are plain copper-nickel, and all of them spend as pocket change.

That includes nearly all Bicentennial quarters from circulation and most dollar coins made since 1971, such as the Eisenhower, Susan B. Anthony and Sacagawea dollars.

Wheat cents, struck from 1909 to 1958, are the coins people most often hope are rare. A few scarce dates exist, but the great majority in worn condition are worth only a little more than face, if anything. A coffee can full of them is worth far less than its weight suggests.

Two coins with San Antonio ties fall in this group. The 2004 Texas state quarter, with the state outline, a star and a lariat, is worth face value in circulated condition.

The 2019 San Antonio Missions National Historical Park quarter, showing wheat, arches, a bell, a lion and the San Antonio River, is also worth face value from circulation. The exceptions are silver proof versions, which carry silver value, and the 2019-W Missions quarter from West Point, which is scarcer than the P and D coins.

We will tell you if a group of coins is worth face value. You do not need to pay anyone to learn that, and our appraisal is free.

How to sort your coins at home

Spread the coins out on a towel under a good light. Pull out anything dated 1964 or earlier, any gold, any silver dollars, and any coin in a holder, album or set. Leave the rest of the clad change in its jar.

Do not clean anything. Cleaning lowers a coin's grade and its price, and collectors pay far less for a coin that has been polished or dipped. Keep coins in the rolls, albums and envelopes you found them in, and keep any notes or receipts with them.

If the collection is large, do not try to sort every coin. Bring it all. We separate collector coins from melt coins at the appointment, so a better date is never priced as bullion.

Write down where each group of coins came from if you know it. A note that says Grandpa's coins from the bank box or Mom's proof sets helps the family keep track, and it helps us hand back anything you decide to keep to the right pile.

Getting a free offer in San Antonio

Call (726) 465-0380 to book a private appointment, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. We call back the same business day. Bring a government-issued photo ID if you plan to sell.

In front of you, we check each coin's date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal under a loupe, and we weigh silver and gold on a calibrated scale you can read. A handful of coins takes about 10 minutes, and a large collection can take 30 to 60 minutes. You get a written, item-by-item offer based on the live spot price for metal and current collector demand for numismatic coins.

Accept the offer and get paid the same day in cash, or by same-day wire for a larger sale. Decline it and keep your coins and the written list.

If you are settling an estate, the written list lets the family or the executor see what each coin is and what we would pay before anyone decides to sell. It is a free purchase appraisal, not a certified appraisal for court, insurance or tax use.

Old coins in San Antonio homes

Old coins come out of San Antonio homes in all sorts of containers. Jars of pre-1965 change saved by a parent who lived through lean years, albums of Lincoln cents started by a child decades ago, and boxes of proof sets bought by the year are all common finds when a house in Terrell Hills, Shavano Park or Stone Oak is cleared out.

Mixed in with them is usually a good deal of clad pocket change that is worth only its face. A single shoebox often holds both kinds.

Local coins add their own confusion. Many residents saved the 2004 Texas quarter and the 2019 San Antonio Missions quarter because of the hometown designs, and they are often surprised to learn that circulated pieces spend as twenty-five cents.

A silver proof Missions quarter or a 2019-W is a different case, and we sort those out for you. Proof sets from many years hold 90% silver coins, and we check those too.

Younger heirs in Schertz and Cibolo, and downsizers moving out of older homes along Broadway, often call us before they know what they have. That is fine.

Call (726) 465-0380 on a weekday between 9am and 5pm, bring everything, and we will separate the coins worth money from the ones worth face. If the collection fills more than a few boxes, ask about a home visit.

Ready to sell? See how we handle selling coins in San Antonio, read about a free coin appraisal, or call (726) 465-0380.

More questions

What old coins are worth money?

Coins made of silver or gold, scarce dates and mint marks, coins in high grade and genuine mint errors. U.S. dimes, quarters and halves dated 1964 and earlier are 90% silver, and pre-1933 U.S. gold coins are 90% gold. We sort and price old coins for free at a private appointment in San Antonio; call (726) 465-0380.

Are wheat pennies worth anything?

Most wheat cents in worn condition are worth only a little more than face, if anything. A few scarce dates and coins in high grade bring a premium. Bring them along with the rest of your coins, and we will check the dates under a loupe and tell you plainly which ones, if any, are worth more.

Is my 2019 San Antonio Missions quarter worth more than 25 cents?

A circulated 2019 San Antonio Missions quarter with a P or D mint mark is worth face value. Silver proof versions carry silver value, and the 2019-W from West Point is scarcer than the P and D coins. The mint mark is a small letter on the front behind Washington's head; bring it to us if you are unsure.

Where can I get old coins looked at in San Antonio?

If you want a second look at what you found, call (726) 465-0380 and set a weekday appointment. We check every coin in front of you, tell you which ones are worth face value, and give a written offer on the rest. The appraisal is free, and you can keep everything if you decline.

See what your coins are worth today

The offer is free, you're under no obligation, and we pay the same day you accept.

(726) 465-0380

Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm

Get your free offer

Tell us what you have. We call back the same business day.

Free and private. We never share or sell your details.