Sell Rare Coins in San Antonio
We buy rare coins from sellers across San Antonio, including scarce dates, mint errors, early American coins and Texas pieces. Every coin is checked under a loupe while you watch, and collector coins are priced on what collectors are paying for them now.
- Free appraisal
- No obligation
- Paid same day
Prefer to talk? (726) 465-0380 · Mon to Fri, 9am to 5pm
Get your free offer
Tell us what you have. We call back the same business day.
$100M+ in gold and coins bought
How rare coins are priced
A rare coin is priced on what collectors pay for that date, mint mark and grade right now. We check published price guides, dealer wholesale sheets and recent auction results before we write a number down.
Any silver or gold in the coin sets a floor under the offer. Eye appeal moves the price within a grade, and a cleaned coin brings far less than an original one.
What sets the price of a rare coin
- The date and mint mark decide how scarce the coin is.
- Grade on the 1 to 70 Sheldon scale moves the price more than anything else.
- Original surfaces sell for more, and cleaning lowers both grade and value.
- Eye appeal, such as even toning and a strong strike, can lift a coin within its grade.
- Collector demand for a series changes over time, so our offers follow current results.
Rare coins we buy
- Scarce date Morgan and Peace dollars
- Carson City coins
- Mint error coins
- Early U.S. cents and half cents
- Early American silver coins
- Pre-1933 U.S. gold
- Texas Centennial half dollars
- Spanish 8 reales
- Mexican 8 reales
- Proof coins
Rare coins with a San Antonio story
People who search for rare coin dealers in San Antonio usually have one or two coins they suspect are worth more than the rest of the jar. We are buyers only, with no inventory to sell you.
Book a private appointment, Monday to Friday between 9am and 5pm, and we look at your coins one at a time under a loupe while you sit across the table. A few pieces take about 10 minutes.
Texas coins get a close look here. The Texas Independence Centennial half dollar was struck from 1934 to 1938 in small runs, and its reverse shows Victory over the Alamo alongside Sam Houston and Stephen F. Austin. An eagle over a lone star fills the obverse.
The coin is 90% silver, yet collectors pay well above that silver. Year, mint mark and grade set the price, so we read all three before we write anything.
Older still are the Spanish 8 reales, the pieces of eight that circulated in Spanish Texas and stayed legal tender in the United States until 1857. After independence, Mexico struck its own 8 reales, and those passed from hand to hand in Mexican Texas.
Most of these coins sell above their silver value. How far above depends on their condition and on the mint that struck them, and we identify both for you.
There has never been a mint in San Antonio, so the S on an old coin points to San Francisco. That letter can matter a great deal. The 1893-S Morgan dollar is a famous rarity, while a 1921 Morgan is a common date holding the same 0.7734 troy oz of silver.
A real mint error can also bring more than a normal coin of the same date. Damage done after a coin left the mint usually adds nothing, and we will tell you which kind you have.
Families who keep old coins in a King William or Monte Vista house sometimes find a rare piece mixed in with ordinary pocket change. We sort the collector coins from the melt coins first, so a better date is never priced as bullion. If the rare coins are part of a large holding, you can ask about a home visit when you book.
Every offer comes in writing, item by item. Say yes and you are paid that day, in cash or by same-day wire for a larger sale, after showing a government-issued photo ID.
Say no and you keep the coins and the list. Call (726) 465-0380 and we will call you back the same business day.
How selling works
Three steps, usually done in one visit.
- 1
Tell us what you have
Fill out the form or call. We call back the same business day and set up a private appointment.
- 2
Get a written offer
We check each coin's date, mint mark, grade and metal while you watch, then write the offer down line by line.
- 3
Get paid the same day
Say yes and leave with cash, or a same-day wire for a large sale. Say no and keep everything.
Questions about selling rare coins in San Antonio
Are you rare coin dealers in San Antonio?
We are buyers. We do not sell coins or metal, so our whole job at the appointment is to look at your rare coins and make a written offer.
Appointments are private and one-on-one, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, and the appraisal is free. Call (726) 465-0380 and we call back the same business day.
What is my Texas Centennial half dollar worth?
It depends on the year, the mint mark and the grade. These halves were struck from 1934 to 1938 in small runs and are 90% silver, but collectors pay well above the silver value. We read the date and mint mark, grade the coin under a loupe and give you a written offer you can keep.
Do you buy Spanish and Mexican 8 reales?
Yes. Spanish 8 reales circulated in Spanish Texas and were legal tender in the United States until 1857, and Mexico struck its own after independence.
Most of them sell above their silver value. The mint and the condition decide by how much, so we check both and price each coin on current collector demand.
Should I clean a rare coin before I bring it in?
Please leave it alone. Cleaning a coin lowers its grade and its value, and collectors pay far less for a cleaned coin.
Keep dirt and toning as they are, store each coin in a holder or envelope and handle it by the edges. We judge the surfaces under a loupe at the appointment.
How do I know if my coin is rare or just old?
Age alone rarely makes a coin rare. The date, mint mark and grade decide it.
An 1893-S Morgan dollar is a famous rarity, while a 1921 Morgan is a common date with the same silver in it. Book a free appraisal and we sort your collector coins from your melt coins in front of you.
Where we buy rare coins around San Antonio
See what your coins are worth today
The offer is free, you're under no obligation, and we pay the same day you accept.
(726) 465-0380Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm
Get your free offer
Tell us what you have. We call back the same business day.