Melt value is what the gold or silver inside a coin is worth at today's spot price. Collector value is what collectors will pay for that coin's date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal. For a gold or silver coin, melt value sets the floor, and collector value is whatever the coin can bring above that floor.
What melt value means
Melt value is the pure metal in a coin multiplied by the spot price of that metal. To find the pure metal, take the coin's weight and multiply it by its purity. Precious metals are priced by the troy ounce, which is 31.1035 grams, a little heavier than the ounce on a kitchen scale.
A Morgan dollar shows how the math works. It weighs 26.73 grams and is 90% silver, so it holds 0.7734 troy ounces of silver.
Multiply that by the day's silver price and you have its melt value. Peace dollars have the same weight and purity, so the result is the same.
Melt value changes every day with the metal markets. It also applies only to coins that contain gold or silver. U.S. coins dated 1965 and later, other than the 1965 to 1970 Kennedy halves, are copper-nickel clad, so their melt value is too low to matter to a seller.
Gold works the same way. A $20 double eagle is 90% gold and holds 0.9675 troy ounces. A one ounce American Gold Eagle weighs 33.93 grams at 22K and still holds one full troy ounce of gold, while 24K coins like the Gold Buffalo and the Canadian Maple Leaf hold their ounce with almost nothing else mixed in.
| Coin | Purity and weight | Pure metal content |
|---|---|---|
| Morgan or Peace dollar | 90% silver, 26.73 grams | 0.7734 troy oz silver |
| $1 face value of dimes, quarters or halves dated 1964 or earlier | 90% silver | About 0.715 troy oz silver |
| American Silver Eagle | .999 silver | 1 troy oz silver |
| $20 double eagle | 90% gold | 0.9675 troy oz gold |
| American Gold Eagle, 1 oz | 22K, 33.93 grams | 1 troy oz gold |
| South African Krugerrand | 22K | 1 troy oz gold |
| Mexican 50 pesos (Centenario) | Gold | 1.2057 troy oz gold |
What collector value means
Collector value comes from how scarce a coin is and what shape it is in. Four things set it: the date, the mint mark, the grade and the eye appeal. Grades run from 1 to 70 on the Sheldon scale, and a coin graded by PCGS or NGC is sealed in a plastic holder called a slab with the grade on the label.
Mint marks tell you where a coin was struck. P or no mark means Philadelphia, D means Denver, S means San Francisco, O means New Orleans, CC means Carson City and W means West Point.
On gold struck before the Civil War, D stands for Dahlonega. Carson City Morgans, struck from 1878 to 1893, draw steady collector interest.
Two Morgan dollars can hold exactly the same silver and sit far apart in price. The 1921 Morgan is a common date.
The 1893-S Morgan is a famous rarity. Their melt values match to the penny, and their collector values are nowhere close.
Condition can move a price as much as the date can. Cleaning a coin lowers its grade and its value, and collectors pay far less for a cleaned coin, so the best thing you can do before an appraisal is leave your coins alone.
Where the two values meet
Every gold or silver coin has both values. For a lot of coins, the collector premium is small and the metal sets most of the offer.
For others, the metal is a small part of the price. Knowing which group a coin belongs to is most of the work in an appraisal.
Bullion coins are made to be bought and sold for their metal, so their offers follow the spot price. Worn 90% silver dimes, quarters and halves, often called junk silver, are usually bought by silver weight too.
At the other end, a Texas Independence Centennial half dollar is 90% silver and still sells to collectors well above its silver value, with the year, mint mark and grade setting how far above. Pre-1933 U.S. gold falls in between: the gold weight is the floor, and a scarce date or a high grade adds to it.
Proof sets show the split well. Silver proof sets carry 90% silver coins in many years, so they always have a melt floor under them. Clad proof sets have none, and anything they bring above face value comes from collectors.
A rough guide to where coins usually land:
- Priced mostly by metal: Silver Eagles, Gold Eagles, Krugerrands, Maple Leafs, Buffaloes, worn 90% silver coins, 40% Kennedy halves and war nickels
- Priced by metal plus collector demand: common-date Morgan and Peace dollars, pre-1933 gold and silver proof sets
- Priced mostly by collectors: scarce dates, Carson City Morgans, Texas Centennial halves, Spanish and Mexican 8 reales, and high-grade slabbed coins
Coins and notes with no melt value
Some things people bring us have no metal worth weighing. Clad coins from 1965 on are the most common.
The 2004 Texas state quarter and the 2019 San Antonio Missions quarter both turn up in jars around town, and circulation pieces of each are worth face value. Silver proof versions carry silver value, and the 2019-W Missions quarter from West Point is scarcer than the P and D.
Paper money has no melt value at all, so whatever it brings comes from collectors. Silver certificates can be redeemed only at face value today.
Large-size notes issued before 1929, star notes, small-size red seal United States Notes and National Bank Notes from 1863 to 1935 can all draw collector demand. Texas bank notes draw regional collectors.
Wheat cents belong here as well. In circulated grades most sell for about face value, though a scarce date or a high grade can change that.
How we decide which value applies
Every coin gets looked at in front of you before anything is priced. We check the date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal under a loupe, and gold and silver go on a calibrated scale you can read. We sort collector coins from melt coins so a better date is never priced as bullion.
For metal, offers follow the live spot price. For numismatic coins, they follow current collector demand, which we check against published price guides, dealer wholesale sheets and recent auction results. You get the offer in writing, item by item, so you can see what each coin brought.
A buyer who only weighs coins will pay melt for everything, including the scarce date at the bottom of the jar. That is the most common way sellers lose money on a mixed collection.
Spanish and Mexican 8 reales show why both checks matter. They are silver, so they have a melt value, and most sell above it. Condition and the mint that struck each one decide how far above.
Reading a melt value you find online
Online melt calculators take the metal content of a coin and multiply it by the spot price. The figure they give is a useful reference for bullion and junk silver. It says nothing about a coin's date, mint mark or grade, so it can sit well below what a collector coin brings.
Gold jewelry and sterling silver have melt values figured the same way. Sterling is 92.5% silver, and a 14K ring is 58.3% gold. Most of these pieces carry no collector value, so weight and purity set the offer on them.
If you want to run the numbers before you call, count the face value of your 1964 and earlier dimes, quarters and halves, and count your silver dollars separately. Set aside anything in a slab or a mint package without opening it. Then call (726) 465-0380 for a free appraisal, and we will show you which coins are priced by metal and which by collectors.
Melt and collector coins from San Antonio homes
A coin appraisal in San Antonio usually turns up both kinds of value in the same box. Jars of pre-1965 dimes and quarters from homes in Universal City, Live Oak and Converse mostly sell by silver weight. A roll of Morgan dollars from the same closet can hide a Carson City date that sells to collectors on its own merits.
Texas coins make the difference easy to see. The Texas Independence Centennial half dollar, struck from 1934 to 1938 with Victory over the Alamo, Sam Houston and Stephen F. Austin on the reverse, is 90% silver and sells well above that silver.
The 2019 San Antonio Missions quarter shows wheat, arches, a bell, a lion and the San Antonio River. Circulation pieces are worth face value, silver proofs carry their silver, and the 2019-W is the scarce one.
An S mint mark stands for San Francisco. There has never been a mint in San Antonio, so no coin carries a local mark, though plenty of S-mint silver dollars ended up in drawers around Bexar County.
We buy by private appointment, Monday to Friday, from sellers across the city and towns like Schertz, Cibolo and Helotes. Phone (726) 465-0380, and a call back comes the same business day.
Ready to sell? See how we handle free coin appraisals in San Antonio, read about selling coins in San Antonio, or call (726) 465-0380.