To sell an inherited coin collection, first leave the coins as you found them, uncleaned and in their original holders, and gather the whole collection in one place. Then have it looked at by a buyer who sorts collector coins from melt coins and puts the offer in writing, coin by coin. With that list in hand, the family or the executor can decide what to sell and what to keep.
Leave everything the way you found it
Most people who call us about a parent's coins have the same first idea. They want to take everything out, wipe off the tarnish and lay it out on the kitchen table. Please wait on that.
Cleaning a coin lowers its grade, and collectors pay far less for a cleaned coin, even one that looked dull and dark before. A silver dollar that has toned in a cigar box for decades is usually worth more left alone.
Holders matter too. Coins sealed by PCGS or NGC in plastic slabs have their grade printed on the label, and that label needs to stay intact.
Proof sets and mint sets should stay in the packaging they came in. Albums, coin rolls and envelopes with handwriting on them can tell a buyer what the collector knew about each piece, so keep them with the coins.
Loose coins in a jar or a coffee can are fine where they are. If you want a rough count, pick coins up by the edges and set them down on a soft towel. Rubbing them together or stacking them tightly can leave marks that show up under a loupe.
If the collector kept a notebook or a price list, hold on to it even if the prices in it are decades old. It shows which coins were bought on purpose and which ones came out of pocket change, and that can point us to the pieces worth a closer look.
Find the whole collection before anyone sells
Collections rarely sit in one box. A collector might keep the gold in a safe, the silver dollars in a closet and a few odd pieces in a dresser drawer.
Military retirees often kept coins from their service years apart from everything else. Take a slow walk through the house before you decide anything, and write down where each group turned up.
It also helps to agree as a family that nobody takes a favorite coin home until the whole collection has been looked at. A coin that seems ordinary can turn out to be the scarce one, and the reverse happens just as often. Places worth checking:
- Gun safes, lockboxes and fireproof boxes
- Dresser drawers and jewelry boxes
- Closet shelves, especially shoe boxes in the back
- Safe deposit boxes at the bank
- Desk drawers holding envelopes of old paper money
- Books and family Bibles, where people tucked silver certificates and large-size notes
What usually turns up in an estate collection
Most estates hold a mix. A few pieces often carry a large share of the worth, and much of the rest is common material bought for its silver or gold.
That's normal. It is also the reason the sorting step deserves so much care, because a better date mixed into a roll of common coins is easy to miss.
Gold jewelry tends to turn up with the coins: wedding bands, class rings, broken chains, an old pocket watch. We sort it by karat and weigh it at the same appointment, so the family doesn't need a second buyer. Gold-filled and gold-plated pieces hold very little gold, and we will point out which ones those are.
Paper money is easy to miss because it lies flat and gets tucked away. Large-size notes issued before 1929 are bigger than the bills in your wallet.
Star notes are replacement notes, marked with a star by the serial number. National Bank Notes from 1863 to 1935 carry the name of the local bank that issued them, and Texas notes draw regional collectors.
The table below lists the groups we see most often in San Antonio estates and what sets the price of each one. Use it to make a rough inventory if you like. You don't need to identify anything before you call us.
| What you find | How to spot it | What sets the offer |
|---|---|---|
| Morgan and Peace dollars | Large silver dollars dated 1878 to 1904 and 1921 (Morgan) or 1921 to 1935 (Peace) | Date, mint mark and grade, with the silver as the floor |
| Old dimes, quarters and halves | Dated 1964 or earlier, 90% silver | Mostly silver weight; better dates priced as collector coins |
| Kennedy halves | Dated 1965 to 1970, 40% silver | Silver content |
| War nickels | Dated 1942 to 1945, 35% silver | Silver content |
| Pre-1933 U.S. gold | $20, $10, $5, $2.50 and $1 gold pieces | Gold weight plus collector demand for the date and grade |
| Modern gold bullion coins | Gold Eagles, Krugerrands, Maple Leafs, Buffaloes | The live spot price of gold |
| Proof and mint sets | Sets in their original mint packaging | Silver content in silver proof years; collector demand for the rest |
| Paper money | Silver certificates, large-size notes, red seals, star notes | Collector demand; silver certificates redeem only at face value |
How to get a fair offer on the collection
Have the collection looked at in one sitting by a buyer who checks each coin. At our appointments, every coin is examined under a loupe for date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal, and the gold and silver go on a calibrated scale you can read. Offers follow the live spot price for metal and current collector demand for numismatic coins.
The biggest risk with an estate is a better date priced as bullion. An 1893-S Morgan and a 1921 Morgan look alike to someone who hasn't handled many silver dollars. Both hold the same silver.
The 1893-S is a famous rarity, and the 1921 is a common date. We sort collector coins from melt coins before anything is priced, so the scarce piece gets a collector price.
Ask for the offer in writing, item by item. A single figure for the whole lot tells the family nothing about which coins carried it. If you want a second opinion from another buyer, take the written list along so both offers cover the same coins.
Be wary of selling in a hurry. A hotel buying event, a pawn shop or a mail-in buyer may weigh the lot and quote one number for all of it. An online marketplace can work for a single coin you know well, but most heirs don't yet know which coins those are, and sorting tells you.
Working with siblings, an executor or an attorney
A written item-by-item list helps families dividing an estate or working with an executor or attorney. Everyone reads from the same page. Nobody has to rely on what Dad once said the collection was worth, and a brother in another state can see the same numbers as the sister who lives here.
Our appraisals are free purchase appraisals, meaning they show what we would pay for each item that day. Keep that in mind if the estate also needs a formal valuation for probate, insurance or tax filings.
If the estate needs one of those, the executor's attorney can tell you what kind is required. Questions about estate paperwork or taxes belong with the attorney or a tax professional.
You can sell part of a collection and keep the rest. Many families hold back a coin or two for the grandchildren, such as a Peace dollar from the year a grandfather was born. The person selling brings a government-issued photo ID to the appointment.
Some families would rather divide the coins than sell them. The written list helps there too. Each line shows what a coin would bring that day, so siblings can use those numbers to split the collection fairly.
Selling the collection with us
Phone (726) 465-0380, and a call back comes the same business day. We work by appointment only, Monday to Friday from 9am to 5pm, and every appointment is private and one-on-one.
Where to meet is set when you book. For a larger collection or an estate, ask about a home visit.
A handful of coins takes about 10 minutes. A large collection can take 30 to 60 minutes. If you accept the written offer, you are paid the same day in cash, or by a same-day wire to your bank for larger sales.
If you decline, you keep every coin and the written list, and the appraisal costs nothing. Bring these with you:
- The whole collection, as you found it
- Albums, holders, boxes and any notes or receipts
- Any list the collector kept
- A government-issued photo ID for the person selling
Inherited coin collections in San Antonio
Families sell inherited coins in San Antonio more often than in most cities, because the area has so many military retirees and long-settled families. Collections come out of homes near Fort Sam Houston, Lackland and Randolph, where a service member set aside silver dollars or bought a proof set each year. They also come out of older houses in King William, Monte Vista and Alamo Heights that have stayed in one family for generations.
Old Texas families sometimes hold pieces with local history attached. A Texas Independence Centennial half dollar shows Victory over the Alamo with Sam Houston and Stephen F. Austin, and it sells to collectors well above its silver value.
Spanish and Mexican 8 reales, the coins that circulated here in Spanish and Mexican Texas, usually bring more than their silver too. Pieces like these get pulled out of the pile and priced on their own.
Heirs often fly in for a few days to settle a house and need answers before it is emptied. We call back the same business day and book appointments Monday to Friday, so the family can leave town with a written list. For a large estate in Terrell Hills, Olmos Park or Shavano Park, or out toward Boerne, New Braunfels and Seguin, ask about a home visit when you call (726) 465-0380.
Ready to sell? See how we handle selling inherited coins in San Antonio, read about a free coin appraisal, or call (726) 465-0380.