PCGS and NGC are the two best-known services for graded coins, and both grade on the same 1 to 70 Sheldon scale. For most coins, a given grade from either company sells at a similar level, and the grade on the label matters far more than the company that issued it. Details grades from either service sell for less.
Who PCGS and NGC are
PCGS, the Professional Coin Grading Service, opened in 1986. NGC, the Numismatic Guaranty Company, followed in 1987.
Both are third-party graders. A collector or dealer sends in a coin, the company's graders assign it a grade, and the coin comes back sealed in a clear, tamper-evident plastic holder that collectors call a slab.
The label on the slab lists the date, mint mark, denomination, grade and a certification number. Both companies back their grades and authenticity with a guarantee, which is a large part of why collectors will buy a slabbed coin they have never held.
Before slabs, buyer and seller had to agree on grade and authenticity coin by coin. A slab settles both questions in advance for most buyers, and that makes graded coins easier to sell.
Other grading services exist, and older collections sometimes hold coins in holders from smaller companies. Those coins are still welcome. Buyers usually price them on their own look at the coin, since the label carries less weight than a PCGS or NGC one.
The grading scale and the label codes
Both services use the Sheldon scale from 1 to 70, and the letters in front of the number tell you the condition range. At the top of the scale, NGC defines a 70 as a coin with no post-production imperfections visible at 5x magnification.
Proof coins, struck twice on polished dies for collectors, are graded on the same 1 to 70 numbers as regular coins. A proof grade carries the PR or PF prefix in place of MS.
Both companies add a plus (+) to coins at the high end of a grade, a practice they announced together in 2010. NGC also adds a star for coins with exceptional eye appeal for their grade. The 1884-CC gold coin in the photo carries a PCGS VF20 grade, the low end of the Very Fine range.
The grade is only half of the price. An MS65 common date can sell for far less than a VF20 scarce date, because the date decides how many collectors want the coin.
- G (Good) 4 to 6: heavy wear, with the main design still visible
- VG and F (Very Good and Fine) 8 to 15: moderate, even wear
- VF (Very Fine) 20 to 35: wear on the high points, with good detail left
- XF or EF (Extremely Fine) 40 to 45: light wear
- AU (About Uncirculated) 50 to 58: traces of wear
- MS (Mint State) 60 to 70: no wear from circulation
- PR or PF (Proof): coins struck for collectors; PCGS prints PR and NGC prints PF
Price differences between PCGS and NGC
For most coins, the difference between the two services is small. Price guides and dealer wholesale sheets track both companies, and in many series they list them close together.
Collectors do argue about which service grades tougher in certain series, and some buyers prefer one label for certain older coins. Those preferences shift over time and vary by coin type, so we price each graded coin by its service, its grade and current collector demand.
The grade itself moves the price far more than the label does. On a scarce date, one point can change the price a great deal, especially in the mint state range.
The coin inside still counts too. Two coins with the same grade can sell differently because one has better eye appeal.
PCGS and NGC both publish price guides. Those figures show retail levels, and what a dealer pays depends on wholesale demand for that coin and grade on the day you sell. Expect an offer below the guide number.
Details grades and Genuine labels
Some coins cannot get a number grade because of a problem like cleaning, scratches, damage or corrosion. NGC labels these with a Details grade, such as AU Details, Improperly Cleaned. PCGS puts them in its Genuine holder with the problem noted, such as Genuine, Cleaned, AU Details.
A Details coin is authentic, and the label tells you roughly what grade it would earn without the problem. It still sells for less than a straight-graded coin. Dealers often price one as if it were a grade or two lower than the label, and each coin is judged on how bad its problem looks.
Cleaning a coin before you send it for grading, or before you sell it, is a costly mistake. Collectors pay far less for a cleaned coin, and both grading services call out the cleaning on the label.
A Details label still has its uses. It tells a buyer the coin is genuine, which matters for gold coins and scarce dates that are often faked. Many Details coins sell for well above melt when the date is scarce enough.
How to check a slab before you sell
Counterfeit holders exist, and some carry real certification numbers copied from genuine coins. PCGS and NGC both let you look up a certification number on their websites and apps.
On a PCGS label, the number sits above the barcode. Both lookups show photos for many coins, so you can compare the coin in your hand with the images.
Check that the date, mint mark, denomination and grade in the lookup match the label, and that the coin matches any photos. NGC flags certification numbers it has seen on fake holders. A cracked, scuffed or reopened slab is a warning sign.
If the lookup shows a different coin, a different grade or no record at all, set the slab aside and mention it when you book. We will look at it with you and explain what we see.
At the appointment, we also look at each graded coin through the plastic under a loupe. The grade on the label is where the offer starts.
Store slabs upright in a box made for them, away from heat. A light scratch on the holder does not change the grade, though a deep one can make the coin harder to see through the plastic.
Selling graded coins in a collection
Leave coins in their holders. Breaking a slab open ends the guarantee and leaves a raw coin that a buyer has to grade from scratch. Older holders are fine to sell as they are, and some collectors look for coins in early holders.
If you have raw coins and wonder whether to send them in, grading costs money and takes time. It tends to pay off for scarce dates and high-grade coins.
On common dates and bullion coins, the fee can eat up most of any gain. At the free appointment, we can point out which of your raw coins might be worth grading.
Many collections mix graded and raw coins. Bring both together, along with any inventory list you have. You get a written, item-by-item offer covering every slab and every raw coin.
Modern bullion coins like Silver Eagles and Gold Eagles also come in slabs, sometimes with labels such as First Strike from PCGS or Early Releases from NGC. These coins are priced on grade like older coins. Their premium over the same coin out of a holder depends heavily on the grade and shrinks quickly below the top grades.
Graded coins in San Antonio collections
Slabbed coins show up in San Antonio collections of every size, from a single PCGS Morgan dollar bought as a gift to boxes of NGC Silver Eagles saved over many years. If you want to sell PCGS or NGC coins in San Antonio, we look at each slab, check the coin through the plastic and price it by service, grade and current collector demand.
Collectors who built graded sets often kept them at home for decades, and heirs in Stone Oak, Helotes, Boerne or New Braunfels may not know what the codes on the labels mean. The written, item-by-item offer spells out each coin, which helps when a family or an executor needs to divide a collection. It is a free purchase appraisal and not a certified appraisal for probate, insurance or tax use.
We meet by private appointment, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. A few slabs take about 10 minutes, and a large graded collection can take 30 to 60 minutes. Bring a government-issued photo ID.
Accept and get paid the same day, in cash or by same-day wire for larger sales, or keep everything along with the list. Call (726) 465-0380. If you have the original grading invoices or a dealer's list, bring those along as well.
Ready to sell? See how we handle selling graded coins in San Antonio, read about a free coin appraisal, or call (726) 465-0380.