Live spot GoldLiveSilverLivePlatinumLive
Mon to Fri, 9am to 5pm · Offers start from today's spot price
San Antonio Coin Buyers

Spanish 8 Reales Value: What Pieces of Eight Are Worth

Coin values · San Antonio Coin Buyers · Updated November 5, 2026

Quick answer

Most Spanish 8 reales, the coins known as pieces of eight, sell for more than their silver value. The type, the mint, the date and the condition decide how much more. Holes, jewelry mounts, heavy chopmarks and cleaning all lower the price, and copies are common, so every piece should be checked before you sell.

Open album of old U.S. coins at a San Antonio coin appraisal

What a piece of eight is

The 8 reales was the large silver coin of the Spanish Empire. Spain struck it at mints across its American colonies, including Mexico City, Lima and Potosí, and it traded around the world. English speakers called it a piece of eight or a Spanish dollar.

The coin circulated in Spanish Texas, and it stayed legal tender in the United States until 1857. The old habit of calling a quarter two bits comes from it: one real was a bit, so a quarter of an 8 reales was two bits.

Mexico won independence in 1821 and went on to strike its own 8 reales with new designs. Those coins circulated in Mexican Texas. Spanish colonial and Mexican republic pieces both come up for sale, and they are priced on different terms, so the first step is knowing which kind you have.

Because the coin was legal tender here for so long, it kept changing hands in Texas well after the United States began striking its own silver dollars.

The four types you are likely to see

Most 8 reales fall into one of four types. The dates in the table are for the Mexico City mint, which made more of these coins than any other. Other mints switched designs on their own schedules, and some kept making hand-struck coins for decades after Mexico City stopped.

Cobs were cut from silver bars, trimmed to weight and struck by hand between two dies. No two look alike. Most are lumpy, the design sits off center, and the date is often missing or only partly visible.

In 1732 Mexico City changed over to machine-made coins with a round shape and a patterned edge meant to stop people from shaving silver off. The pillar type shows two globes under a crown, set between two pillars. In 1772 a portrait of the king, starting with Charles III, took over the front, and the crowned shield moved to the back between the two pillars.

A cob can be hard to date. Collectors identify many of them by the shield, the cross and whatever mint and assayer marks remain visible, and a cob with a clear, full date draws more interest than one without.

TypeMexico City datesHow to spot it
CobBefore 1732Irregular hand-struck shape, design often off center
Pillar (columnario)1732 to 1771Two crowned globes between two pillars, no portrait
Portrait (bust)1772 to 1821King's portrait on the front, crowned shield between pillars on the back
Mexican republicAfter independenceEagle on a cactus on one side, a cap with rays on the other

Mint marks and assayer initials

Coins from Mexico City carry the mint mark Mo, an M with a small o above it. Lima, Potosí and the other colonial mints each used their own mark.

On pillar coins the mint mark appears on both sides of the date. On portrait coins it sits on the back beside the shield, next to the denomination.

Beside the mint mark you will usually see one or two capital letters. Those are the initials of the assayers, the officials who vouched for the silver in the coin. Collectors use the date, the mint and the assayer initials together to identify an exact coin, and some combinations are far scarcer than others.

Mexico City struck by far the most 8 reales, so its coins are the easiest to find and the easiest to price. Coins from smaller mints, and some early pillar dates, draw more collector interest. Condition still sets the price within each date.

Portrait coins name the king in the legend around the bust. Charles III, Charles IV and Ferdinand VII all appear on Mexico City 8 reales, and the name helps narrow down the date on a worn coin.

What decides the price

Silver sets the floor. Every genuine 8 reales is a large silver coin, and its melt value follows the spot price. Most sell above that floor because collectors want them for their history, and how far above depends on type, mint, date and condition.

Damage matters more on these coins than many people expect. A lot of pieces of eight were drilled, looped or soldered into necklaces and watch fobs over the years.

A hole or mount cuts the collector price, though the coin still sells. Cleaning does the same kind of harm, so leave a dark or dirty coin alone.

Coins that traded in China often carry small punched marks called chopmarks, put there by merchants testing the silver. Collectors treat chopmarked coins as their own group. A few neat marks may not bother a buyer much, while a coin covered in them usually brings less.

Coins recovered from shipwrecks are another group. Years in seawater can leave them corroded, pitted and light in weight, and buyers pay less for that kind of surface. Any paperwork from the salvage, or a certificate that came with the coin, should stay with it.

  • Type: cob, pillar, portrait or Mexican republic
  • Mint and assayer initials
  • Whether the full date shows
  • Wear, and whether the coin has been cleaned
  • Holes, mounts, solder or chopmarks
  • Sea salvage surfaces and any paperwork

Copies and souvenir pieces

Copies of pieces of eight are common. They were sold as souvenirs, gift shop items and pirate props, and some have been in families so long that nobody remembers where they came from.

Some are silver-colored base metal. Others are real silver cast in a mold taken from a genuine coin.

A cast copy often has soft, mushy details, a grainy or bubbly surface, a seam around the edge, or the wrong weight. Some are stamped COPY in small letters. A genuine milled coin has crisp lettering and a clean edge pattern.

We check every piece under a loupe and can weigh it on a calibrated scale in front of you before we make an offer. If a piece turns out to be a copy, we tell you plainly, and you keep it.

Plated pieces show up as well. A coin with a thin silver wash over brass or copper may look right at first, but worn high points often show a different color underneath, and the weight usually comes up short.

Selling pieces of eight in San Antonio

Call (726) 465-0380 to book a private, one-on-one appointment, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. We call back the same business day. Bring the coins as you found them, along with any envelopes, tags or notes, plus a government-issued photo ID if you plan to sell.

We identify each coin by type, mint and date, check its condition under a loupe and weigh the silver on a calibrated scale. You get a written, item-by-item offer based on the spot price for metal and current collector demand.

Accept it and get paid the same day in cash, or by same-day wire for a larger sale. Decline it and keep everything, including the list.

Families with pieces of eight often keep other old foreign silver in the same box, such as Mexican pesos or coins brought home from travel. Bring all of it. We weigh silver by purity and set aside anything collectors want more than its metal.

If the coins are part of an estate, the written, item-by-item list lets the family or the executor see what each piece is and what we would pay for it before anyone decides.

Spanish and Mexican silver in San Antonio

San Antonio began in 1718 with a Spanish mission and presidio on the San Antonio River, and the missions south of downtown, San José, Concepción, San Juan and Espada, have been a UNESCO World Heritage Site since 2015. Spanish silver was the money of that frontier, and Mexican 8 reales took its place after 1821, so these coins carry real local history for the families who own them.

Pieces of eight reach us in a few different ways. Some come from old South Texas families who kept a coin or two for generations. Others were bought as souvenirs decades ago, or mounted on a necklace or watch chain and later found in a jewelry box in King William or Castle Hills.

Military retirees sometimes picked them up during overseas service. The story rarely tells us what the coin is, so we check each one.

Booking is the same from Helotes to Universal City. Call (726) 465-0380 on a weekday between 9am and 5pm, and we set the meeting place when you book. For a large estate, ask whether a home visit is possible.

Bring every piece, including ones you suspect are copies, and we will sort them for you at no charge. A worn coin with no visible date can still be identified by its type and its mint marks.

Ready to sell? See how we handle selling rare coins in San Antonio, read about a free coin appraisal, or call (726) 465-0380.

More questions

How much is a Spanish 8 reales coin worth?

Most sell for more than their silver value. The type, mint, date and condition decide how much more, and holes, mounts, heavy chopmarks and cleaning bring the price down.

We look at each coin in front of you and give a free, written offer based on current collector demand. Call (726) 465-0380 to book.

How can I tell if my piece of eight is real?

Copies often have soft details, a grainy surface, a seam on the edge or the wrong weight, and some are stamped COPY. A genuine milled coin has crisp lettering and a clean edge. We check every piece under a loupe and on a calibrated scale before we make an offer, and we tell you plainly if one is a copy.

Do you buy Mexican 8 reales from after independence?

Yes. We buy Mexican republic 8 reales along with Spanish colonial cobs, pillar coins and portrait coins.

The republic coins show an eagle on a cactus on one side and a cap with rays on the other. They are priced on their own terms, by mint, date and condition, and we sort them at the appointment.

Where can I sell pieces of eight in San Antonio?

To have your reales looked at in person, call (726) 465-0380 on a weekday between 9am and 5pm. We identify and weigh each coin in front of you and give you a written offer.

Accept and get paid the same day, or decline and keep your coins and the list. The appraisal is free.

See what your coins are worth today

The offer is free, you're under no obligation, and we pay the same day you accept.

(726) 465-0380

Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm

Get your free offer

Tell us what you have. We call back the same business day.

Free and private. We never share or sell your details.