A pre-1933 U.S. gold coin is worth at least the gold inside it. Most common dates in circulated grades sell for their melt value plus a small premium, while scarce dates, better mint marks and high grades can bring much more. A $20 double eagle holds 0.9675 troy oz of gold, so its price starts there.
The U.S. gold coins struck before 1933
U.S. gold coins were struck for circulation until 1933. Nearly every old gold piece a San Antonio family brings us belongs to one of the series listed here, and the denomination and design tell us where to start before we look at the date.
The $20 coins are called double eagles, the $10 coins eagles, the $5 coins half eagles and the $2.50 coins quarter eagles. Augustus Saint-Gaudens designed both the $10 and $20 coins first struck in 1907. Bela Lyon Pratt designed the Indian Head $2.50 and $5, whose design is sunk below the surface of the coin instead of raised above it.
Before you call, look at each coin and write down three things: the denomination, the date and any small letter near the date or on the back. That short list is enough to book an appointment, and it tells us how much time to set aside.
- $20 Liberty Head double eagle, 1850 to 1907
- $20 Saint-Gaudens double eagle, 1907 to 1933
- $10 Liberty Head eagle, 1838 to 1907
- $10 Indian Head eagle, 1907 to 1933
- $5 Liberty Head half eagle, 1839 to 1908
- $5 Indian Head half eagle, 1908 to 1929
- $2.50 Liberty Head quarter eagle, 1840 to 1907
- $2.50 Indian Head quarter eagle, 1908 to 1929
- $1 gold dollar, 1849 to 1889
Start with the gold inside the coin
Classic U.S. gold coins are 90% gold. The other 10% is mostly copper, which made the coins harder so they held up in circulation.
From 1837 on, every dollar of face value held the same amount of gold, so gold content scales with the denomination. A $10 eagle holds half the gold of a $20, and a $5 holds a quarter of it.
To find melt value, multiply the gold content in the table by the day's spot price. That figure is the floor for the coin.
A worn common date trades near it, and a scarce or high-grade coin trades above it. Our offers on gold coins follow the live spot price, so the melt figure moves with the market from one day to the next.
Gold content is the same for every date in a denomination as it left the Mint. A worn 1880s eagle and a sharp 1920s eagle hold the same gold, so the difference in their prices comes from the collector premium. Ten double eagles hold 9.675 troy oz of gold between them, which is why a small stack of $20 pieces can add up quickly at today's spot price.
| Coin | Face value | Pure gold (troy oz) |
|---|---|---|
| Double eagle | $20 | 0.9675 |
| Eagle | $10 | 0.4838 |
| Half eagle | $5 | 0.2419 |
| Quarter eagle | $2.50 | 0.1209 |
| Gold dollar | $1 | 0.0484 |
Common dates and scarce dates
Most pre-1933 gold trades as common-date coins, and dealers often buy and sell those by type and grade without much attention to the exact year. Their price follows gold closely, with a premium that depends on grade and on how much demand there is for that type at the moment.
Some years were struck in small numbers, some mints made few coins of a given denomination, and many coins were melted later. Those coins are priced on collector demand first and gold content second.
Carson City gold, marked CC, draws strong collector interest. So does gold from the Dahlonega, Georgia mint, which carries a D and dates from before the Civil War.
Price guides, dealer wholesale sheets and recent auction results show where a date sits. We look up every gold coin by date and mint mark instead of pricing a stack by weight, because a buyer who only weighs gold will pay bullion money for a better date. Sorting the collector coins from the melt coins happens before any offer is written.
Some years come in more than one type, and the type changes the price. In 1907 the Mint struck both Liberty Head and Saint-Gaudens double eagles.
The first Saint-Gaudens coins left off the motto IN GOD WE TRUST, and it was added in 1908, so a 1908 double eagle can be either a No Motto or a With Motto coin. We check for these differences on every coin before we price it.
Finding the mint mark
A mint mark is a small letter showing which Mint struck the coin. Gold coins with no letter came from Philadelphia. On pre-1933 gold you will also see S for San Francisco, O for New Orleans, CC for Carson City, C for Charlotte, North Carolina, which struck gold before the Civil War, and D.
A D on a coin from before the Civil War means Dahlonega, and a D on a coin dated 1906 or later means Denver. There has never been a mint in San Antonio.
Where to look depends on the design. On a Liberty Head double eagle, the mint mark sits on the back, below the eagle. On a Saint-Gaudens double eagle it is on the front, just above the date.
On the Indian Head $2.50 and $5, look on the back to the left of the arrowheads. The letters are small and wear down on circulated coins, so a loupe helps.
Never scratch or rub a coin to read a worn mint mark. We read them under magnification at the appointment, with you watching.
Grade, cleaning and eye appeal
Grade is the condition of a coin on the 1 to 70 Sheldon scale. Gold is soft, and heavy coins like double eagles were shipped in bags, so many show small nicks called bag marks. A double eagle with few marks and full original luster can grade well above one that knocked around in a bag, and on scarce dates the price gap between grades can be wide.
The Indian Head $2.50 and $5 are harder to grade. Because the design is sunk into the coin, the highest points on these coins are the flat fields, and the fields take wear first. Gold coins that were mounted in jewelry, soldered or drilled usually sell near their gold value, since collectors want coins that were never altered.
Cleaning does more harm to gold coins than most people expect. Polishing strips the original surface and leaves fine lines that a collector spots right away, and collectors pay far less for a cleaned coin. Leave old gold exactly as you found it, dirt and all.
Grade on gold is read at the high points of the design, where wear shows first. On a Saint-Gaudens double eagle, that means Liberty's chest and knee.
On a Liberty Head coin, look at the hair above her forehead. Fine detail still showing in those spots usually means a higher grade and, on better dates, a higher price.
Counterfeits, graded coins and what to bring
Fake gold coins exist, and some contain real gold. Each coin gets checked under a loupe for date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal, then weighed on a calibrated scale you can read yourself. If a coin looks or weighs wrong, we show you what we see.
Coins already graded by PCGS or NGC stay in their holders. The grade on the label is where pricing starts, and we still look at the coin through the plastic.
For the appointment, bring the coins as they are, in whatever envelopes, tubes or boxes they came in, plus a government-issued photo ID. A handful of gold coins takes about 10 minutes.
You get a written, item-by-item offer. Accept and get paid the same day in cash, or by same-day wire for larger sales, or decline and keep your coins and the list.
If you have receipts, old invoices or an inventory from when the coins were bought, bring them. They help us match coins to records and are useful for your own files. You do not need any paperwork to sell.
Pre-1933 gold in San Antonio estates
Old U.S. gold turns up in San Antonio homes more often than people expect. Long-time families and military retirees from Fort Sam Houston, Lackland and Randolph put away a few double eagles decades ago, and those coins often sit untouched in a dresser drawer or a safe deposit box until an estate is settled. If you want to sell gold coins in San Antonio, start by learning which of yours are common dates and which are not.
We meet sellers by appointment, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, across the city and nearby towns, from Alamo Heights and Monte Vista inside Loop 410 to Stone Oak, Boerne and New Braunfels farther out. Where to meet is set when you book. Families settling a larger estate can ask about a home visit.
Mexican gold often sits beside U.S. coins in South Texas collections, so bring all of it together. A Mexican 50 pesos holds 1.2057 troy oz of gold, more than a double eagle holds. The written list you get helps heirs or an executor divide coins fairly.
It is a free purchase appraisal, and it is not a certified appraisal for probate or insurance. If the coins came out of a safe deposit box, keep them in the envelopes or holders they were stored in until the appointment, since a note on an old envelope sometimes tells us where or when a coin was bought.
Ready to sell? See how we handle selling gold coins in San Antonio, read about a free coin appraisal, or call (726) 465-0380.