Every Morgan silver dollar is worth at least its silver value, because each one holds 0.7734 troy ounce of pure silver. Common dates in worn condition trade close to that melt figure. The date, the mint mark and the grade decide how far above it a coin goes, and Carson City coins, scarce dates and high-grade pieces bring the most.
The Morgan dollar at a glance
The Morgan dollar is named for George T. Morgan, the Mint engraver who designed it.
It was struck from 1878 to 1904, then again in 1921. The front shows Liberty in profile, and the back shows an eagle with its wings spread inside a wreath.
Each coin weighs 26.73 grams and is 90% silver, which works out to 0.7734 troy ounce of pure silver. That figure never changes, so the silver in a Morgan is easy to price on any given day. It follows the live spot price, and it is the least a genuine Morgan is worth.
Peace dollars, struck from 1921 to 1935, have the same weight and silver content. The two often turn up mixed together in the same roll, coin tube or cigar box. We price them on the same terms, but the date list that matters is different for each series.
The design stayed the same through the whole run, so dates and mint marks are the main way to tell one Morgan from another. Specialists also look for die varieties, small differences between the dies used to strike the same date, and a few of those carry a premium.
Where to find the mint mark
Turn the coin over. On a Morgan, the mint mark sits on the back, just below the wreath and above the letters DO in DOLLAR. A coin with no letter there was struck at Philadelphia.
The mint mark matters because the same date can be common from one mint and scarce from another. A Morgan with CC under the wreath came from Carson City, Nevada, which struck Morgans only between 1878 and 1893, and not in every one of those years. Collectors pay a premium for almost any CC Morgan.
Look closely, because the letters are small and wear can soften them. An O or S on a worn coin can be hard to read without a magnifier. People sometimes add a fake CC to a common coin, so we check the mint mark on every Carson City dollar under a loupe.
The Mint also struck proof Morgans for collectors, with mirror fields and sharp details. They are much scarcer than coins made for circulation, so show us any dollar that looks unusually crisp and shiny before you set it in the common pile.
| Mint mark | Mint | Morgan years |
|---|---|---|
| None | Philadelphia | 1878 to 1904, 1921 |
| O | New Orleans | 1879 to 1904 |
| S | San Francisco | 1878 to 1904, 1921 |
| CC | Carson City | 1878 to 1893, with gaps |
| D | Denver | 1921 only |
Dates that matter and dates that don't
Most Morgans are common dates. The 1921 Morgan is the most common of all, since the Mint struck it in huge quantities from three mints in a single year.
A worn 1921 trades close to its silver value. Many dates from the 1880s are common too, especially from Philadelphia and San Francisco.
At the other end, the 1893-S is a famous rarity, and a handful of other dates and mint pairs are scarce enough that collectors watch for them. A scarce date is worth far more than a common one in the same grade, which is why we never price a roll of Morgans by weight without checking every date and mint mark.
If you are sorting at home, set aside the coins listed below and leave the rest together. We check each date at the appointment, so you do not need to look anything up.
Peace dollars have their own short list of better dates and mint marks, separate from the Morgan list. On a Peace dollar the mint mark sits on the back, near the bottom left, and we check those coins one by one in the same way.
- Any coin with CC under the wreath
- O and S coins from the 1890s and early 1900s
- Coins with little or no wear on Liberty's cheek and hair
- Coins with mirror-like fields
- Any Morgan already in a PCGS or NGC slab
How grade changes the price
Grading runs on the 1 to 70 Sheldon scale. A Morgan with heavy wear, where Liberty's hair and the eagle's breast feathers have rubbed flat, is priced mostly on silver unless the date is scarce. As wear decreases, the collector premium grows, and in the mint state grades, 60 and up, small differences in grade can change the price sharply.
Morgans were stored and shipped in large cloth bags, so many uncirculated coins carry bag marks, small nicks from rubbing against other dollars. Fewer marks, especially on Liberty's cheek, mean a higher grade. Some coins have mirror-like fields called prooflike surfaces, and collectors pay more for those.
Toning can go either way. Even, colorful toning can add to the price. Dark or spotty toning usually takes away from it.
Cleaning always hurts. A cleaned Morgan has fine hairline scratches and an unnatural shine, and collectors pay far less for it. Do not polish, dip or wipe your dollars, even the dark ones.
Rolls, bags and mixed lots
Many families kept silver dollars in bank rolls, canvas bags, coin tubes or plain boxes. Bring them as they are. If a roll is still wrapped, leave it closed; we open it in front of you and go through every coin.
Mixed lots often hold more than Morgans and Peace dollars. Eisenhower dollars look like silver, but the ones made for circulation are copper-nickel clad and worth face value. Some versions sold to collectors contain silver, and we check the mint mark and packaging to tell them apart.
Susan B. Anthony and later dollar coins contain no silver at all, and we will tell you so if a roll turns out to be one of those.
Graded Morgans in PCGS or NGC slabs should stay in their holders. We price them on the grade shown, the eye appeal of the coin itself and current collector demand.
Counterfeit Morgans exist, and many are good enough to pass a quick look. Weight is the first test. A genuine Morgan weighs 26.73 grams, and we put every dollar on a calibrated scale you can read.
How we price Morgans at an appointment
Call (726) 465-0380 to book a private appointment, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, and we call back the same business day. Bring a government-issued photo ID if you plan to sell. A few dollars take about 10 minutes, and a large hoard can take 30 to 60 minutes.
In front of you, we check each coin's date, mint mark, grade and eye appeal under a loupe, and we weigh the silver on a calibrated scale you can read. Common dates are priced from the live spot price of silver. Better dates and high-grade coins are priced on current collector demand, so a scarce Morgan is never paid out as melt.
You get a written, item-by-item offer. Accept and get paid the same day in cash, or by same-day wire to your bank for a larger sale.
Decline and keep every coin, plus the written list. The appraisal is free with no obligation.
Executors and heirs get the same written list, item by item. It helps when a collection is divided among family or reviewed with an attorney before a sale.
Silver dollars in San Antonio families
San Antonio has been a military city for generations, and Joint Base San Antonio, made up of Fort Sam Houston, Lackland and Randolph, has brought service families here from every part of the country. Many retirees stayed.
Silver dollars saved by a parent or a grandparent tend to travel with those families from posting to posting, so Morgans from all five mints turn up in homes from Universal City to Converse to Live Oak. Most are common dates, and every so often a CC coin turns up that someone picked up decades ago.
Ranch and Hill Country families have their own habit of keeping silver dollars. We see rolls and tubes of Morgans and Peace dollars from acreage properties around Helotes and Boerne, sometimes tucked away with old pocket watches and other keepsakes. In older neighborhoods like Alamo Heights and Monte Vista, they often surface during a move or an estate sale, still in the bank wrappers they came in.
Wherever your dollars came from, the appointment works the same. A single coin is welcome, and so is a canvas bag of them. Call (726) 465-0380 on a weekday between 9am and 5pm, and we agree on where to meet when you book.
Owners of a large hoard or a full estate can ask about a home visit. Keep the rolls closed and the coins uncleaned until we see them.
Ready to sell? See how we handle selling silver dollars in San Antonio, read about a free coin appraisal, or call (726) 465-0380.